Hey, there! Log in / Register

In Allston/Brighton race, Cashman would get tough on local colleges, Breadon would make developers build more affordable housing

Cashman and Breadon at forum

Cashman and Breadon at forum.

At a debate at WGBH tonight, Craig Cashman and Liz Breadon made one of their last pitches to voters on why they should replace Mark Ciommo, retiring as the District 9 (Allston/Brighton) city councilor after 12 years. Whoever wins will serve two years.

Among the issues they discussed:


Breadon said the neighborhood's affordable-housing crisis was what led her to announce her candidacy even before Ciommo announched his retirement. She said there are currently 17,000 people on waiting lists for affordable housing in the neighborhood, that the "affordable" units developers of thousands of new units are not actually affordable for many current residents and that the problem is only worsening due to "extortionate speculation" by out-of-town investors.

Breadon said the city needs to up the percentage of new development projects that are set aside for affordable housing from the current 13% to as much as 20%, in part because, unlike some other neighborhoods, Allston/Brighton does not have significant numbers of city-owned vacant lots on which such housing could be built. But she said some projects should go even highter - she pointed to the large Stop & Shop Allston Yards proposal, which she said should be at least 25% affordable, in part because the company already owned the land.

"I think we all feel the suffocation of the development going on in this community," Cashman said. But he said the neighborhood does have government-owned spaces that could be built on for affordable housing, especially after creation of a "community housing trust" that would collect funds from developers for such projects. He pointed to little used DCR land on Leo Birmingham Parkway and land next to the fire station on Chestnut Hill Avenue. "These parcels exist." He suggested that the Jackon-Mann School has enough land to allow for both a new school and housing for the middle class.

Holding institutional land owners to account

Both said some of the neighborhood's large instutions are not really fulfilling their voluntary Payment in Lieu of Taxes payments to the city - in particular Boston College.

Breadon said city assessors need to revalue BC's land - something she said hasn't been done in ten years. And institutions need to better account for the benefits they say they're providing. It's good that BC is providing scholarships for Boston residents, but how many and to whom, she asked.

Cashman said he would force BC and other large institutions to pay the full value of their PILOT payments by threatening to hold up the required BPDA approval they need for any expansion. "Most of them are still trying to expand," and holding up the approval they need would sent a clear message, he said, adding that neighborhoods without large non-profits are earning more in community benefits from private landowners than Allston/Brighton is from the colleges and other institutions with land in the neighborhood. He noted the idea would work particularly well with Harvard, which is seeking BPDA approval for its massive Allston Landing proposal to remake the old Allston rail yard. "We should be having that conversation now," he said.

Public transit

Cashman called on the state to accelerate development of West Station at the former Allston train yards, which he said would allow not just for another stop on the Worcester Line but as the beginning of a new crosstown line across the Charles River and into and beyond Kendall Square. But he said the more important thing a city councilor could do is advocate for ways to speed up bus service in the neighborhood, from looking at the possibility of bus-only lane and even streets and traffic-signal changes that would turn lights green for oncoming buses. He said Boston also needs to regain a seat on one of the boards that oversees the T.

Breadon said she's aghast at the "huge inequalities" in public transit - such as workers at a local nursing home who spend 90 minutes getting there from their homes in Roxbury and Mattapan. She acknowledged there's a limit to what one city councilor can do, but said that that's where organizing comes in - just like when 500 people showed up one night to save the Faneuil library branch.


Breadon said she supported at-large Councilor Michelle Wu's proposal to charge for residential parking permits if the money raised can be invested in such things as bicycle infrastructure. But she said to really free up spaces for residents, the city needs to address all the Brookline, Newton and out-of-state college students she said not clog up valuable parking spaces in the neighborhood. "It's past time that we address the issue of so many people parking in our neighbrhood who aren't residents of our neighborhood and people from out of state" and ensure that only people who pay excise taxes to Boston can park here.

Cashman opposed the proposal, at least for a resident's first car, saying the city shouldn't be taxing residents even more. He said the city needs to post more streets as "resident only" and to go after people who obviously live in Allston/Brighton but who register their cars elsewhere - he said he and his wife paid $817 in excise this year for their 2018 Highlander while the guy around the corner with the New Jersey plates on his Mercedes is paying Boston nothing. He said establishing a maximum visitor period and then strongly enforcing that would work particularly well with, say, a BC student facing a call from his parents about the bill for towing his car away from Foster Street.

Cashman said he would work with business owners in the neighborhood's business districts to try to get businesses partnering on sharing their existing spaces. He pointed to the almost aways empty Citizens Bank lot in Brighton Center as an example of a lot that might prove valuable for evening valet parking at nearby residents.

Breadon said the city needs to do a better job just putting up signs pointing people to existing municipal lots, such as the one behind the Corrib in Brighton Center or the one behind Blanchard's in Allston. Not everybody knows they're public lots, rather than belonging to the businesses in front of them, she said.

The role of a district city councilor

Breadon said part of her job would be to encourage alliances between Allston/Brighton residents and people in other neighborhoods with similar issues to create greater advocacy on key issues. She pointed to Mission Hill as another neighborhood beset with issues related to institutional expansion. She said she would call on her 20 years as a community activist, on such issues as keeping the Faneuil branch library open and finding a new use for the Presentation School, to fight for such issues.

Cashman said he would focus on constituent issues, right down to something like a situation on Etna Road, where during some door knocking, a resident said he really wanted to see stop signs installed at the intersection with Elmira Street. At the same time, though, he said that after 12 years as a district liason for state Rep. Michael Moran, he realizes that getting anything done takes somebody on the inside, who knows which buttons to push and levers to pull. He said he knows who to call at City Hall and the State House to get things done. "There's no loearning curve for me at this point."

Breadon, a physical therapist, said her job would make her equally adept at community services, because a key part of her job is not just helping patients with direct physical care, but in connecting them and their caretakers with additional services.


Both agreed the process for replacing the Jackson-Mann School has been awful and that BPS simply needs to do a better job both at coming up with a plan to ensure the neighborhood actually gets a good new school and that parents are brought in the loop so they can plan on what to do when the school is torn down.

Both also said the current test system for getting into exam schools needs to be re-evaluated, in part to ensure that poorer BPS students get the same sort of test prep as affluent kids. Breadon suggested adding a point system - a kid who had come up from kindergarten in BPS would get extra points towards exam-school admission.

Breadon also called for more resources for Madison Park, the city's only vocational school, which she said is failing to prepare its students for jobs in the booming Boston economy. She compared Worcester vocational school, which has a waiting list of 200 students, with Madison Park, which she said is so poorly regarded it has 200 empty seats. She addded that Brighton High School, where 65% of the students are either in special-education or English-learning programs, should get more resource from BPS.

Cashman called for expanding the BPS early childhood programs - and said colleges in the city could help BPS make that happen.

Overall priorities

Breadon cited the need to better fund Boston public schools - Boston shouldn't have schools where drinking fountains are connected to lead pipes and where the heating doesn't work - and making Allston/Brighton schools safer.

Cashman agreed on the need for fully funding schools, but said he is also concerned that Boston maintain its current good bond rating, because should that decline through too much spending, the city would be unable to meet other priorities - such as building a new Jackson-Mann.




"extortionate speculation" by out-of-town investors ...?

Trust me, no out of town investor is trying to get rich by investing in Allston or Brighton.

Voting closed 2

I live in Brighton. Speculators have been getting rich here for years. Near to my home, there is a two-family, built as two apartments, each with two bedrooms, kitchen, living room, dining area, one bath. I remember families there. NOW: first floor has three bedrooms, one kitchen, one bath. Second floor: FOUR bedrooms, one kitchen, one bath. THE ENTIRE YARD IS PAVED. It's a mess. It's a rooming house.

Voting closed 4


Voting closed 7

I have the same issue on my street in Dorchester. A 2 family house was sold and converted to a rooming house, with zero building permits pulled (until neighbors complained) and no variances applied for or granted. We have problems with overflowing trash in their yard and on the street, rats, parking on the sidewalk (even though they paved the entire yard), noise, loud parties past midnight during the work week and the weekend, and rat infestations.

Attempts to talk to the owner and residents are met either with anger and threats, or with lip service. Despite numerous neighbors contacting ISD and 311, nothing has changed. Some 311 complaints have been addressed, some have not, but they keep on happening.

Recent news has confirmed what many of us suspected all along. Some individuals in the city government who are supposed to control this kind of thing are on the take.

Your glib dismissal of anon's concerns are disingenuous. There is no way you would be happy if this happened next door to you and you would absolutely be complaining. It's easy to dismiss others with accusations of nimby-ism but it's a real and a growing problem in this city.

Voting closed 0

Hell, I lived in a house with roommate turnover and individual leases for 15 years. It was cheap. I didn't need to live like a prince in a competitive city in my 20s...and I didn't.

Voting closed 8

Forgot to add, there is an illegal apartment in the basement, too.

Yeah, the horror. As in when there's a fire.


Voting closed 12

Yep. No one is making money over at Boston Landing. Or at any of the other new outsized over priced developments in the area. They are just doing it for fun. We may not be Beacon Hill but we are still ripe for the picking for someone to make some handsome profits

Voting closed 15

Trust me, no out of town investor is trying to get rich by investing in Allston or Brighton.

That statement is simply false and surprising from someone who should know better. Did someone hack your account?

Voting closed 16

Thank you Adam for doing this — really appreciate the work.

Voting closed 57

But Cashman sounds much more reasonable.

Breadon sounds like she has no clue about budget realities or even how the tax and budget systems work.

Fully funding schools? Some day I'd love for somebody to give me an answer to how much that is. Every time I ask, the answer just comes back "more!".

Voting closed 39

Boston has an excellent bond rating. An enormous amount of development leads to lots of revenue, outside the Prop 2 1/2 limits. Where is that money going? There is plenty of cash to pay for the Jackson Mann rebuilding, its staff, and other initiatives.

It is a disgrace that Boston has a sub-par vocational school. Maybe not the sexiest topic, but Liz is highlighting something important. All the construction, all the unions, all the high tech, all the contractors, all doing well. And what? Time for all of them to step up.

Voting closed 7

Is the voc school subpar.

Check the budget. It's not about money. We spend more than enough, just not wisely.

Voting closed 24

Americans owe $1.6 trillion to an industry which makes almost literally nothing. The person talks, you take the test, you get a piece of paper.

Public education is a con at its current price point.

Voting closed 11

education is expensive, try ignorance."

Voting closed 4

Fiscal discipline is overrated, try irresponsible spending.

Hell, if you're going to quote a pithy bumper sticker about education, you didn't even pick the best one. The winner is "It'll be a great day when schools have all the money they need and the Air Force needs to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber."

Voting closed 11

Breadon can call herself an affordable housing advocate all she wants but when it comes to the Stop and Shop housing proposal, she has demanded smaller buildings with fewer units. Not the first project she has tried to downsize both in size and scope, resulting in fewer overall and affordable set aside units. She’s your typical lefty Boomer NIMBY homeowner that we have more than enough of already in this city. Cashman doesn’t seem to know a lot or really stand out at all but I’ll take an empty suit over a reactionary activist like Breadon. Next time A-B needs actual good candidates to run.

Voting closed 43

fighting against greedy landlords trying to build oversized developments does not mean you are against housing. The theme of both candidates is anti developers who are destroying the fabric of the neighborhood

Voting closed 24

The overwhelming feeling in the neighborhood is that the project IS too big, and no one in city hall seems to care one bit about overall planning. Even getting a public meeting was a fight. The developer refuses to provide green space that would be legally protected from future building. And yes, developers are always proposing projects that are bigger than they know will be approved. The S&S transit plan is that everyone will use the New Balance rail stop, or walk to Union Square and take the bus. Yeah, right.

Voting closed 18

From the very 1st S&S development mtg she advocated for housing that working people could afford, in particular young adults and older adults, as well as spaces for families.
Same thing at St Gabriel’s.
She’s served on Affordability Committee of CDC for years.
And her closing comment last night was something about a welcoming, diverse AB.
She’s more of a YIMBY.

Voting closed 9

So their idea for more affordable housing is not to incentivize building more housing overall, but rather to force developers to reclassify some more units to affordable housing?

Nothing they are doing is going to result in more housing being built, just how they are going to be allocated.

Voting closed 21

Cashman is a goon. Breadon is a homeopath.

It's lose-lose.

Thankfully nobody cares about A-B and the city council is largely powerless.

Voting closed 11

They can’t make developers build more affordable housing even if they really wanted to. Let’s assume that one of these new city councilors will agree to be the only city councilors not to take payoffs from developers, they still have to get the ZBA to do the right thing. The ZBA is made up of DEVELOPERS (and realtors and architects— same family). They only do what is in their best interests.

Voting closed 7

Awful public policy.

Voting closed 5